MLB HR picks · Tuesday, May 19, 2026

Top 5 went 1/5 on home runs.

1

Ben Rice

NYYvsTOR· vs Dylan Cease

73.9

20.2%

✅

1 HR

2

Byron Buxton

MINvsHOU· vs Jason Alexander

71.3

19.6%

❌

0 HR

2

Kyle Schwarber

PHIvsCIN· vs Chase Burns

70.5

19.4%

❌

0 HR

3

Aaron Judge

NYYvsTOR· vs Dylan Cease

66.6

18.5%

❌

0 HR

4

Jordan Walker

STLvsPIT· vs Mitch Keller

64.1

17.8%

❌

0 HR

4

Munetaka Murakami

CWSvsSEA· vs Bryce Miller

64.8

18.0%

❌

0 HR

5

JJ Bleday

CINvsPHI· vs Jesús Luzardo

63.9

17.7%

❌

0 HR

6

Bryce Harper

PHIvsCIN· vs Chase Burns

63.6

17.6%

❌

0 HR

7

Yordan Alvarez

HOUvsMIN· vs Zebby Matthews

63.5

17.6%

❌

0 HR

8

Paul Goldschmidt

NYYvsTOR· vs Dylan Cease

62.8

17.4%

❌

0 HR

9

Michael Conforto

CHCvsMIL· vs Jacob Misiorowski

62.8

17.4%

❌

0 HR

10

Mike Trout

LAAvsATH· vs Jacob Lopez

62.5

17.3%

✅

1 HR

11

Kazuma Okamoto

TORvsNYY· vs Will Warren

62.3

17.3%

❌

0 HR

12

James Wood

WSHvsNYM· vs Nolan McLean

59.9

16.6%

✅

1 HR

12

Elly De La Cruz

CINvsPHI· vs Jesús Luzardo

61.7

17.1%

❌

0 HR

13

Casey Schmitt

SFvsAZ· vs Ryne Nelson

60.9

16.9%

❌

0 HR

14

Shea Langeliers

ATHvsLAA· vs Reid Detmers

60.5

16.8%

❌

0 HR

15

Luke Raley

SEAvsCWS· vs Anthony Kay

60.5

16.8%

❌

0 HR

16

Ian Happ

CHCvsMIL· vs Jacob Misiorowski

59.5

16.5%

❌

0 HR

17

Hunter Goodman

COLvsTEX· vs Tyler Alexander

59.2

16.4%

❌

0 HR

17

Sal Stewart

CINvsPHI· vs Jesús Luzardo

59.4

16.4%

❌

0 HR

18

Trent Grisham

NYYvsTOR· vs Dylan Cease

59.4

16.4%

❌

0 HR

19

Brandon Lowe

PITvsSTL· vs Matthew Liberatore

58.6

16.2%

❌

0 HR

20

Justin Foscue

TEXvsCOL· vs Sammy Peralta

58.4

16.1%

❌

0 HR

21

Ryan Jeffers

MINvsHOU· vs Lance McCullers Jr.

57.8

15.9%

❌

0 HR

21

Juan Soto

NYMvsWSH· vs Foster Griffin

58.1

16.0%

✅

1 HR

22

Brandon Valenzuela

TORvsNYY· vs Will Warren

56.5

15.6%

❌

0 HR

22

Mickey Moniak

COLvsTEX· vs Tyler Alexander

57.7

15.9%

❌

0 HR

23

Oneil Cruz

PITvsSTL· vs Matthew Liberatore

57.6

15.9%

❌

0 HR

24

Nick Kurtz

ATHvsLAA· vs Reid Detmers

56.7

15.6%

❌

0 HR

25

Zach Cole

HOUvsMIN· vs Zebby Matthews

56.0

15.4%

❌

0 HR

26

Spencer Steer

CINvsPHI· vs Jesús Luzardo

55.8

15.3%

❌

0 HR

26

Moisés Ballesteros

CHCvsMIL· vs Jacob Misiorowski

55.9

15.4%

❌

0 HR

27

Junior Caminero

TBvsBAL· vs Kyle Bradish

55.6

15.3%

❌

0 HR

28

Gavin Sheets

SDvsLAD· vs Emmet Sheehan

55.8

15.3%

❌

0 HR

28

Zack Gelof

ATHvsLAA· vs Reid Detmers

55.1

15.1%

✅

1 HR

29

Mark Vientos

NYMvsWSH· vs Foster Griffin

55.0

15.1%

❌

0 HR

30

Kody Clemens

MINvsHOU· vs Jason Alexander

54.3

14.9%

❌

0 HR

31

Nathaniel Lowe

CINvsPHI· vs Jesús Luzardo

55.1

15.1%

❌

0 HR

31

Angel Martínez

CLEvsDET· vs Keider Montero

54.0

14.8%

❌

0 HR

32

Bobby Witt Jr.

KCvsBOS· vs Ranger Suarez

53.9

14.7%

❌

0 HR

33

Dillon Dingler

DETvsCLE· vs Parker Messick

53.5

14.6%

❌

0 HR

34

Pete Alonso

BALvsTB· vs Griffin Jax

53.2

14.5%

❌

0 HR

35

Randal Grichuk

CWSvsSEA· vs Bryce Miller

54.4

14.9%

❌

0 HR

35

Corbin Carroll

AZvsSF· vs Landen Roupp

53.2

14.5%

❌

0 HR

36

Harrison Bader

SFvsAZ· vs Ryne Nelson

53.1

14.5%

❌

0 HR

37

Drew Romo

CWSvsSEA· vs Bryce Miller

53.9

14.7%

❌

0 HR

37

José Tena

WSHvsNYM· vs Nolan McLean

52.6

14.3%

✅

1 HR

38

Max Muncy

LADvsSD· vs Griffin Canning

53.8

14.7%

❌

0 HR

38

Christian Walker

HOUvsMIN· vs Zebby Matthews

52.6

14.3%

❌

0 HR