MLB HR picks · Sunday, May 17, 2026

Top 5 went 1/5 on home runs.

1

Matt Olson

ATLvsBOS· vs Brayan Bello

73.4

20.1%

❌

0 HR

2

Drake Baldwin

ATLvsBOS· vs Brayan Bello

70.0

19.3%

❌

0 HR

3

Ben Rice

NYYvsNYM· vs Freddy Peralta

69.7

19.2%

✅

1 HR

4

Aaron Judge

NYYvsNYM· vs Freddy Peralta

69.7

19.2%

❌

0 HR

5

Kyle Schwarber

PHIvsPIT· vs Paul Skenes

67.7

18.7%

❌

0 HR

6

Munetaka Murakami

CWSvsCHC· vs Colin Rea

67.2

18.6%

❌

0 HR

7

Michael Harris II

ATLvsBOS· vs Brayan Bello

64.8

18.0%

❌

0 HR

8

Jordan Walker

STLvsKC· vs Stephen Kolek

64.0

17.8%

❌

0 HR

8

Yordan Alvarez

HOUvsTEX· vs Nathan Eovaldi

66.2

18.4%

❌

0 HR

9

James Wood

WSHvsBAL· vs Brandon Young

62.5

17.3%

❌

0 HR

10

Mickey Moniak

COLvsAZ· vs Michael Soroka

62.3

17.3%

❌

0 HR

10

Luke Raley

SEAvsSD· vs Lucas Giolito

63.5

17.6%

❌

0 HR

11

JJ Bleday

CINvsCLE· vs Gavin Williams

62.1

17.2%

❌

0 HR

11

Byron Buxton

MINvsMIL· vs Robert Gasser

61.8

17.1%

❌

0 HR

12

Casey Schmitt

SFvsATH· vs Jeffrey Springs

61.3

17.0%

❌

0 HR

13

Zach Cole

HOUvsTEX· vs Nathan Eovaldi

59.8

16.6%

❌

0 HR

14

Nick Kurtz

ATHvsSF· vs Adrian Houser

59.5

16.5%

❌

0 HR

15

Juan Soto

NYMvsNYY· vs Elmer Rodríguez

59.2

16.4%

❌

0 HR

16

Colson Montgomery

CWSvsCHC· vs Colin Rea

59.0

16.3%

❌

0 HR

17

Bryce Harper

PHIvsPIT· vs Paul Skenes

58.8

16.3%

✅

1 HR

18

Kazuma Okamoto

TORvsDET· vs Jack Flaherty

58.9

16.3%

❌

0 HR

18

Mike Trout

LAAvsLAD· vs Roki Sasaki

58.5

16.2%

❌

0 HR

19

Hunter Goodman

COLvsAZ· vs Michael Soroka

58.3

16.1%

❌

0 HR

20

Elly De La Cruz

CINvsCLE· vs Gavin Williams

57.2

15.8%

✅

1 HR

20

Willson Contreras

BOSvsATL· vs Grant Holmes

58.5

16.2%

❌

0 HR

21

Drew Romo

CWSvsCHC· vs Colin Rea

57.6

15.9%

❌

0 HR

21

Michael Conforto

CHCvsCWS· vs Erick Fedde

57.0

15.7%

✅

1 HR

22

Miguel Vargas

CWSvsCHC· vs Colin Rea

56.2

15.5%

❌

0 HR

22

Randal Grichuk

CWSvsCHC· vs Colin Rea

57.5

15.9%

❌

0 HR

23

Brent Rooker

ATHvsSF· vs Adrian Houser

58.3

16.1%

❌

0 HR

23

Trent Grisham

NYYvsNYM· vs Freddy Peralta

56.0

15.4%

❌

0 HR

24

Christian Walker

HOUvsTEX· vs Nathan Eovaldi

57.6

15.9%

❌

0 HR

24

Harrison Bader

SFvsATH· vs Jeffrey Springs

55.6

15.3%

✅

1 HR

25

Nathaniel Lowe

CINvsCLE· vs Gavin Williams

55.0

15.1%

❌

0 HR

26

Zack Gelof

ATHvsSF· vs Adrian Houser

54.7

15.0%

❌

0 HR

26

Shea Langeliers

ATHvsSF· vs Adrian Houser

56.3

15.5%

❌

0 HR

27

Ian Happ

CHCvsCWS· vs Erick Fedde

54.6

15.0%

❌

0 HR

28

Austin Riley

ATLvsBOS· vs Brayan Bello

54.2

14.8%

✅

1 HR

29

Dominic Smith

ATLvsBOS· vs Brayan Bello

54.0

14.8%

❌

0 HR

30

Dillon Dingler

DETvsTOR· vs Kevin Gausman

53.9

14.7%

❌

0 HR

31

Mark Vientos

NYMvsNYY· vs Elmer Rodríguez

53.7

14.7%

❌

0 HR

32

Bobby Witt Jr.

KCvsSTL· vs Andre Pallante

53.6

14.7%

❌

0 HR

33

Jac Caglianone

KCvsSTL· vs Andre Pallante

54.2

14.8%

❌

0 HR

33

Angel Martínez

CLEvsCIN· vs Brady Singer

53.3

14.6%

✅

1 HR

34

Brandon Valenzuela

TORvsDET· vs Jack Flaherty

52.9

14.4%

❌

0 HR

35

Paul Goldschmidt

NYYvsNYM· vs Freddy Peralta

54.0

14.8%

❌

0 HR

35

Gavin Sheets

SDvsSEA· vs George Kirby

52.8

14.4%

✅

2 HR

36

Sal Stewart

CINvsCLE· vs Gavin Williams

52.7

14.4%

❌

0 HR

37

Corbin Carroll

AZvsCOL· vs Michael Lorenzen

52.7

14.4%

✅

2 HR

38

Max Muncy

LADvsLAA· vs Grayson Rodriguez

52.5

14.3%

❌

0 HR