MLB HR picks · Tuesday, May 12, 2026

Not yet settled. Results post the next morning.

1

James Wood

WSHvsCIN· vs Brady Singer

76.8

28.7%

2

Jordan Walker

STLvsATH· vs Jeffrey Springs

74.2

27.5%

3

Munetaka Murakami

CWSvsKC· vs Stephen Kolek

73.8

27.3%

4

Kyle Schwarber

PHIvsBOS· vs Jovani Morán

73.6

27.2%

5

Nick Kurtz

ATHvsSTL· vs Andre Pallante

72.3

26.6%

6

JJ Bleday

CINvsWSH· vs Miles Mikolas

72.2

26.5%

7

Elly De La Cruz

CINvsWSH· vs Miles Mikolas

71.6

26.2%

8

Sal Stewart

CINvsWSH· vs Miles Mikolas

68.2

24.3%

9

Yordan Alvarez

HOUvsSEA· vs Bryan Woo

67.9

24.1%

10

Shohei Ohtani

LADvsSF· vs Adrian Houser

67.7

24.0%

11

Shea Langeliers

ATHvsSTL· vs Andre Pallante

67.4

23.8%

12

Colson Montgomery

CWSvsKC· vs Stephen Kolek

66.4

23.2%

13

CJ Abrams

WSHvsCIN· vs Brady Singer

66.3

23.1%

14

Alec Burleson

STLvsATH· vs Jeffrey Springs

66.3

23.1%

15

Nathaniel Lowe

CINvsWSH· vs Miles Mikolas

66.2

23.0%

16

Aaron Judge

NYYvsBAL· vs Trevor Rogers

65.9

22.9%

17

Mike Trout

LAAvsCLE· vs Slade Cecconi

65.8

22.8%

18

Byron Buxton

MINvsMIA· vs Eury Pérez

65.7

22.7%

19

Spencer Steer

CINvsWSH· vs Miles Mikolas

65.2

22.4%

20

Ben Rice

NYYvsBAL· vs Trevor Rogers

64.7

22.1%

21

Luis García Jr.

WSHvsCIN· vs Brady Singer

64.3

21.8%

22

Jac Caglianone

KCvsCWS· vs Erick Fedde

64.3

21.8%

23

Max Muncy

LADvsSF· vs Adrian Houser

63.4

21.3%

24

Brent Rooker

ATHvsSTL· vs Andre Pallante

63.3

21.2%

25

Dominic Canzone

SEAvsHOU· vs Tatsuya Imai

62.7

20.8%

26

Luke Raley

SEAvsHOU· vs Tatsuya Imai

62.5

20.7%

27

Brady House

WSHvsCIN· vs Brady Singer

62.3

20.5%

28

Matt Olson

ATLvsCHC· vs Colin Rea

62.2

20.5%

29

Bryce Harper

PHIvsBOS· vs Jovani Morán

61.5

20.0%

30

Drake Baldwin

ATLvsCHC· vs Colin Rea

61.4

19.9%

31

Pete Alonso

BALvsNYY· vs Will Warren

61.0

19.7%

32

Jake Bauers

MILvsSD· vs Bradgley Rodriguez

60.8

19.5%

33

Will Benson

CINvsWSH· vs Miles Mikolas

60.6

19.4%

34

Miguel Vargas

CWSvsKC· vs Stephen Kolek

60.6

19.4%

35

Bobby Witt Jr.

KCvsCWS· vs Erick Fedde

60.6

19.4%

36

Tyler Soderstrom

ATHvsSTL· vs Andre Pallante

60.4

19.3%

37

Zack Gelof

ATHvsSTL· vs Andre Pallante

60.3

19.2%

38

Hunter Goodman

COLvsPIT· vs Paul Skenes

60.0

19.0%

39

Jackson Chourio

MILvsSD· vs Bradgley Rodriguez

60.0

19.0%

40

Freddie Freeman

LADvsSF· vs Adrian Houser

59.9

18.9%

41

Ty France

SDvsMIL· vs Brandon Sproat

59.5

18.7%

42

Pete Crow-Armstrong

CHCvsATL· vs Grant Holmes

59.1

18.4%

43

Matt McLain

CINvsWSH· vs Miles Mikolas

58.8

18.2%

44

Corbin Carroll

AZvsTEX· vs MacKenzie Gore

58.8

18.2%

45

Dillon Dingler

DETvsNYM· vs Freddy Peralta

58.2

17.8%

46

Corey Seager

TEXvsAZ· vs Zac Gallen

58.1

17.7%

47

Ryan Jeffers

MINvsMIA· vs Eury Pérez

57.9

17.6%

48

Casey Schmitt

SFvsLAD· vs Yoshinobu Yamamoto

57.8

17.5%

49

José Tena

WSHvsCIN· vs Brady Singer

57.7

17.5%

50

Kazuma Okamoto

TORvsTB· vs Shane McClanahan

57.7

17.5%