MLB HR picks · Saturday, May 9, 2026

Not yet settled. Results post the next morning.

1

Kyle Schwarber

PHIvsCOL· vs Kyle Freeland

77.1

28.8%

2

Yordan Alvarez

HOUvsCIN· vs Chase Burns

76.3

28.5%

3

Munetaka Murakami

CWSvsSEA· vs Luis Castillo

74.2

27.5%

4

Byron Buxton

MINvsCLE· vs Tanner Bibee

70.4

25.5%

5

Shohei Ohtani

LADvsATL· vs Spencer Strider

69.1

24.8%

6

JJ Bleday

CINvsHOU· vs Spencer Arrighetti

68.3

24.3%

7

Elly De La Cruz

CINvsHOU· vs Spencer Arrighetti

68.2

24.3%

8

Aaron Judge

NYYvsMIL· vs Kyle Harrison

67.6

23.9%

9

Juan Soto

NYMvsAZ· vs Merrill Kelly

67.3

23.7%

10

Colson Montgomery

CWSvsSEA· vs Luis Castillo

66.8

23.4%

11

Ben Rice

NYYvsMIL· vs Kyle Harrison

65.7

22.7%

12

Jake Bauers

MILvsNYY· vs Cam Schlittler

64.4

21.9%

13

Nick Kurtz

ATHvsBAL· vs Shane Baz

64.2

21.8%

14

Jackson Chourio

MILvsNYY· vs Cam Schlittler

64.0

21.6%

15

Hunter Goodman

COLvsPHI· vs Aaron Nola

63.8

21.5%

16

Christian Walker

HOUvsCIN· vs Chase Burns

63.7

21.4%

17

James Wood

WSHvsMIA· vs Janson Junk

63.2

21.1%

18

Nathaniel Lowe

CINvsHOU· vs Spencer Arrighetti

62.6

20.7%

19

Mickey Moniak

COLvsPHI· vs Aaron Nola

62.4

20.6%

20

Pete Alonso

BALvsATH· vs Aaron Civale

61.2

19.8%

21

Kody Clemens

MINvsCLE· vs Tanner Bibee

61.2

19.8%

22

Pete Crow-Armstrong

CHCvsTEX· vs Jack Leiter

61.1

19.7%

23

MJ Melendez

NYMvsAZ· vs Merrill Kelly

60.5

19.3%

24

Randal Grichuk

CWSvsSEA· vs Luis Castillo

60.4

19.3%

25

Dillon Dingler

DETvsKC· vs Michael Wacha

60.2

19.1%

26

Corey Seager

TEXvsCHC· vs Edward Cabrera

60.1

19.1%

27

Miguel Vargas

CWSvsSEA· vs Luis Castillo

60.1

19.1%

28

Spencer Steer

CINvsHOU· vs Spencer Arrighetti

59.7

18.8%

29

Willson Contreras

BOSvsTB· vs Nick Martinez

59.5

18.7%

30

Ian Happ

CHCvsTEX· vs Jack Leiter

59.4

18.6%

31

Samuel Basallo

BALvsATH· vs Aaron Civale

59.3

18.5%

32

Jordan Walker

STLvsSD· vs Randy Vásquez

59.1

18.4%

33

Michael Conforto

CHCvsTEX· vs Jack Leiter

58.8

18.2%

34

Corbin Carroll

AZvsNYM· vs Clay Holmes

58.8

18.2%

35

Dalton Rushing

LADvsATL· vs Spencer Strider

58.7

18.1%

36

Gunnar Henderson

BALvsATH· vs Aaron Civale

58.3

17.9%

37

Matt Olson

ATLvsLAD· vs Blake Snell

58.3

17.9%

38

Cam Smith

HOUvsCIN· vs Chase Burns

58.2

17.8%

39

Drake Baldwin

ATLvsLAD· vs Blake Snell

58.2

17.8%

40

Justin Foscue

TEXvsCHC· vs Edward Cabrera

57.5

17.3%

41

Julio Rodríguez

SEAvsCWS· vs Anthony Kay

57.4

17.3%

42

Jarred Kelenic

CWSvsSEA· vs Luis Castillo

57.1

17.1%

43

Junior Caminero

TBvsBOS· vs Payton Tolle

57.0

17.0%

44

Zach Dezenzo

HOUvsCIN· vs Chase Burns

56.7

16.8%

45

Andy Pages

LADvsATL· vs Spencer Strider

56.7

16.8%

46

Shea Langeliers

ATHvsBAL· vs Shane Baz

56.3

16.6%

47

Joc Pederson

TEXvsCHC· vs Edward Cabrera

56.1

16.4%

48

Zach Neto

LAAvsTOR· vs Trey Yesavage

55.9

16.3%

49

Will Benson

CINvsHOU· vs Spencer Arrighetti

55.8

16.2%

50

Mark Vientos

NYMvsAZ· vs Merrill Kelly

55.3

15.9%